2014年份：Remarkably restrained, refined and highly northern Rhone of scent: ground pepper, blue fruits and charcuterie; a skein of hi-fi acidity embedded in the mid-weighted frame, towing the flavours clear and long. Very good indeed. Atypical of the region on some levels, although blue fruit billows across the palate as the wine opens.

94分

-James Halliday

2012年份：從外觀上看，儘管葡萄酒呈現的色調不錯，對葡萄的品種和產區而言，顏色還是十分淺淡；塔奴丹莊園的葡萄酒或多或少在芳香和風味之外有一絲酸度凸顯，這款葡萄酒也不例外。

86分

——James Halliday詹姆斯·哈利德